1. Education

Discuss in my forum

Readers Respond: I disagree (or agree) with the article on Aryan Invasion, because...

Responses: 115

By , About.com Guide

Shree Arya Putra part two

Additionally other words and rules of grammar are also common with European languages and Sanskrit however there are many inconsistencies with the European languages following the complete set of rules or use of words. Since we have historical fact based proof of human migration from India to Europe such as that of the Gypsies we can conclude that there may have been other migration waves in the past that we may not know about. The Aryan invasion theory supposed the opposite of the Gypsie migration that there were Nordic people who came to India and contributed or wrote the Vedas. There are no I repeat ZERO cultural or geographic traces of references to Europe or their language in the vedas but Gypsies do however carry traces of their home land to Europe
—Guest Arya Putra

Shree Arya Putra part one

Their are so many fallacies in the European belief of what Aryans were or are and the so called invasion theory. There is not enough time or space here to explain all. Based on archeological evidence in Europe and known human migration patterns we know for a fact that Gypsies came from India. We also know that there were waves of migrations of Gypsies. We also know for a fact there is a linguistic relationship between Sanskrit and European languages. With the fact of Gypsies migration to Europe we also know that they maintain their language and traditions even after more than a thousand years. The linguistic evidence suggests that European languages have bits and pieces of Sanskrit. Case in point. the word ignorance in Sanskrit is agnan very similar however in English there is no opposite word for ignorance but in Sanskrit it is gnan. We also note there is a logic in Sanskrit grammar when a vowel is placed in front of a word it makes it the opposite or such as infinite or finite.
—Guest Arya Putra

pl read current theories

The AIT has already been abandoned by Romila Thapar, Witzel and others — let’s not flog a dead horse .. there is no living mainstream scholar who beleives in the AIT anymore Those who claim that the Indus was Vedic are politically motivated.. so are those who support the Dravidian hypothesis 1. Sanskrit was a liturgical language not the language of the masses 2. The IVC originated in Baluchistan – Vedic culture originated in the Vedic homeland 3. IVC was based on contacts with Mesopotamia – Vedic culture was not 4. We have to account for all aspects of Hinduism not Vedism alone the transfer of power happened through a series of acculturations . There are very detailed acculturation models proposed by the Allchins, Jim Shaffer. I have proposed a 150 page acculturation model -posted above. While most of those who beleive in the VIT are innocent, this is a part of the BJP’s greater plan to eliminate muslims and christians. As Indians lets be wary and keep the larger interes
—SujayRao

aryan invasion

The popular belief of the aryan invasion has to go/ aryan land was from egypt to combodia and tibet to batticaloa in lanka/ shades of sanskrit languages can be seen in english and other european languages/sansrit is the mother of all european languages/ the centre of aryan land was afghanistan is true/ I stay 6000 kms from herat in afghanistan and my language is malayalam which is 70 percent sanskrit, and i heard the afghani people using a lot of words of my regional language
—Guest suresh

The "Aryan Invasion"Theory has loopholes

The "Aryan Invasion"Theory has loopholes 1. The Europeans do not speak or write Sanskrit. 2. There is no mention about Europe/Iran in any of the Vedas or Puranas (Khandar in Afghansithan is mentioned) 3. The Indians were much superior to the Europeans not only in Marine Navigation, but Medicine (Ayurveda), Martial Arts- Kalari, Military Science (Dhanurveda), Music & Dance (Ghandava Veda), Astrology, Astronomy, etc. These were all put down on palm leaves. A lot of these books & Science were destroyed by the British just like the Taliban does it today. Western medicine was born only recently with the discovery of Penicillin. Even today the West try to Patent Indian medicinal discoveries like Neem, Tumeric etc. Most of these theories like Darwin & Aryan Theory are forwarded by Freemason "part-time" researchers trying to link their supramacy theory to anything that they can get their hands on.
—Guest Johnson

complete and comprehensive solution

Please go through my complete and comprehensive solution for the so-called Aryan problem. part 2 is very important. it is the longest research paper published in the humanities in india and is written in such a way that anyone who tries to refute one part of the hypothesis will contradict himself somewhere else http://www.scribd.com/doc/27103044/Sujay-NPAP-Part-One http://www.scribd.com/doc/27105677/Sujay-Npap-Part-Two Mirror: http://www.docstoc.com/docs/25880426/Sujay-NPAP-Part-One http://www.docstoc.com/docs/25865304/SUJAY-NPAP-Part-Two journal :: Part one http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=1324506 Part Two http://ssrn.com/abstract=1541822 Sujay Rao Mandavilli Sujay
—SujayRao

complete and comprehensive solution

Please go through my complete and comprehensive solution for the so-called Aryan problem. part 2 is very important. it is the longest research paper published in the humanities in india and is written in such a way that anyone who tries to refute one part of the hypothesis will contradict himself somewhere else http://www.scribd.com/doc/27103044/Sujay-NPAP-Part-One http://www.scribd.com/doc/27105677/Sujay-Npap-Part-Two Mirror: http://www.docstoc.com/docs/25880426/Sujay-NPAP-Part-One http://www.docstoc.com/docs/25865304/SUJAY-NPAP-Part-Two journal :: Part one http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=1324506 Part Two http://ssrn.com/abstract=1541822 Sujay Rao Mandavilli Sujay
—SujayRao

solution to so-called Aryan problem

Please find my complete solution for the socalled Aryan problem Part one is a high level overview. Part two is much more interesting This is one of the longest research papers published in a peer-reviewed journal since independance. http://www.scribd.com/doc/27103044/Sujay-NPAP-Part-One http://www.scribd.com/doc/27105677/Sujay-Npap-Part-Two > Mirror: http://www.docstoc.com/docs/25880426/Sujay-NPAP-Part-One http://www.docstoc.com/docs/25865304/SUJAY-NPAP-Part-Two Part one - Basic model with proof http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=1324506 > Part Two detailed model with conclusions (Must read) http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=1541822
—Guest SujayRao

solution for socalled aryan problem

Please go through my complete and comprehensive solution for the so-called Aryan problem. I am sure you'll like them. part 2 is very important. it is the longest research paper published in the humanities in india and is written in such a way that anyone who tries to refute one part of the hypothesis will contradict himself somewhere else http://www.scribd.com/doc/27103044/Sujay-NPAP-Part-One http://www.scribd.com/doc/27105677/Sujay-Npap-Part-Two Mirror: http://www.docstoc.com/docs/25880426/Sujay-NPAP-Part-One http://www.docstoc.com/docs/25865304/SUJAY-NPAP-Part-Two journal :: Part one http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=1324506 Part Two http://ssrn.com/abstract=1541822 Sujay Rao Mandavilli
—SujayRao

Haha

It is funny how my painstakingly written response to this article was not displayed, because it didn't agree with the article.
—Guest Guest

German stupidity

How is it that a country of people who r responsible 4 such brilliant engineering feats r also stupid enough 2 fall 4 Hitlers vision of a blond haired blue eyed super race that he was 2 b the leader of who extolled Jews 2 b vermin when Hitler WAS of jewish ancestry with brown hair & eyes & no one questioned this!?!?!?! What idiots, more like a super stupid race. And 2 the woman who has a son in the Aryan brotherhood, please invite your son & all his friends over 4 dinner & poison their food & do the world a HUGE favor. And what of german women 2day who r fascinated with sleeping with blacks, that's a smart way 2 go about keeping your so called Aryan super race alive. I personally would b ashamed 2 admit I was of german descent considering your history of arrogance & stupidity.
—Guest Guest Dino

skeptical

I wouldn't give the theory any credence based on what I read here. The aryan hypothesis recalls efforts in North America to portray the mound builders as something other than native Americans (because dark-skinned people couldn't possibly create an advanced culture) or efforts to conceal the origins of Great Zimbabwe (same reason), or for that matter aliens visiting South America and sharing their advanced technology with the natives. I sense a pattern.
—Guest bej

Aryans' Invasion theory

Theory had been made contestable due to the British author Macaulay’s designs, who wanted to establish his theory that if the Britishers were invaders so were the Aryans. The pity is, History is usually distorted by historians for personal, political and national interest at times and designed differently willfully. Whereas this is true that Indians went to China and Russia and then through the Bering land bridge (which was a land bridge roughly 1,000 miles (1,600 km) north to south at its greatest extent and which joined present-day Alaska and eastern Siberia at various times during the Pleistocene ice ages) reached Alaska and were called the Native Indians. It has been admitted that Vedas were written in Sanskrit and was the language of Aryans. It has also been admitted that Sanskrit is the mother of all languages. Sanskrit was read, spoken and written only in India. All these well recognised and admitted facts lead to believe that Aryans were the Native Indians of Bharat Indi
—Rajeshnd

Seriously?

Time to rant! A. The Invasion theory goes perfectly with the word "Aryan" meaning "Noble" or "Nobleman" because the Aryan invasion established a caste system with them on top, more or less "nobles". B. @ Guest Ysbaddaden- Helena Petrovna Blavatsky was a theosophist, not a historian or anything of value to this argument. Theosophy is a religious philosophy and Metaphysics. C. @ Guest themomma- Believe it or not, the media actually shows a false portrayal (often) of Persians. Persians do generally NOT look like Arabs, look like Caucasians, are very closely related to the Greeks (No, the Macedonian invasion did not "whiten" them), and sometimes DO have blond hair and blue eyes. Green eyes are actually not rare at all there. The whole idea is, if you look at it, the Caucasians/Aryans/Indo-Europeans/whatever are the only race that will often have blond hair and blue eyes. In other races it is often some kind of mutation. (Continued in Next Post)
—Guest Soup Nazi

Historian, author, writer and journalist

India is called Aryavarta - the abode of the Aryas. In the 8th Chapter of his world famous book, Satyarth Prakash, Maharishi Dayanand Saraswati describing The Creation , Sustenance and Dissolution of The Universe, quoting the reference from the oldest Scriptures Vedas, writes that the mankind was created by God in Trivishtap otherwise called Tibet. They were divided into two main classes, - The good were called Aryas and the wicked Dasyus. Says the Rig Veda, "Do ye know (there are) two classes of men - Aryas and Dasyus." The good and learned were also called Devtaas, while the ignorant and wicked, such as dacoits (robbers), were called Asura. .("RIG VEDA 2: 51, 8) This division into Aryas and Shudras is supported by the Atharva Veda wherein it is said "Some are Aryas, others Shuudras..( ATHARVA VEDA19:62) When the relations between the Aryas and Dasyus, or between Devas and Asuraas, (i.e., between the good and learned, and the ignorant and wicked) developed into a constant stat
—Guest samual henry

Share Your Opinion

I disagree (or agree) with the article on Aryan Invasion, because...

Receive a one-time notification when your response is published.

©2013 About.com. All rights reserved.