From the article: Who Were the Aryans?
The Aryan Invasion Theory is one of the most hotly contested theories in archaeology today, in part because it is caught up in the politics of the region. Here you can make your best claims for the support of your side. Be aware that answers are moderated, so keep your arguments non-personal. Share Your Opinion
The People of Indus Valley Are the Aryan
- I beleive in it. If they were so much civilized they may have moved from the valley to the ganges planes.
- —Guest Ojasva Raj
Vedic Civilization
- The so called Harappa civilization is nothing but the urban culture of Vedic Civilization. See http://ithihas.wordpress.com/2013/05/02/the-vedic-civilization-part-i/ http://ithihas.wordpress.com/2013/05/04/the-vedic-civilization-part-ii/
- —Guest Raghu
complete solution to aryan problem
- some people complianed that some links were troublesome.. i have provided alternative links (as applicable) Yes.. the "aryan problem" isn't complex .. just break it down into its logical components! The Demise of the Dravidian, Vedic and Paramunda Indus myths I am publishing my sixth research paper directly online as it is an extension of my previous papers. Kindly read pages 4 to 18 as it contains a detailed discussion of the term ‘Aryan’. This paper shows why the Dravidian, Vedic and Paramunda Indus theories are not tenable. http://www.scribd.com/doc/136268397/The-demise-of-the-Dravidian-Vedic-and-Paramunda-Indus-myths Methods to reconstruct the languages of the Harappans were presented in the present and previous papers. We hope other scholars take up the exercise of reconstructing the languages of the Indus Valley civilization! The older papers were written taking the assumptions of the 19th century school of Indology as a base and working backwards. These may appear
- —Guest Sujay Rao Mandavilli
Aryan Theory is racist
- I strongly disagree with the Aryan theory. Max Mueller, a British and hence color-minded, could only think of color differences between North and South Indias in terms of ethnicity! Aryan Theory is therefore a racist outcome of a racist mind. North Indians are as much Indians as South Indians and nobody invaded North India from Central Asia. India is a unique land bounded by Hindu Kush & Himalayas to the north, and it is difficult to cross-over from Asia to India through these; hence the importance of Khyber Pass! Also, Sankskrit is an Indian language and not Central Asian. 'Arya' in Sanskrit means 'Guru' keeping sync with India's Ancient Guru-Shishya Paramparaa and does not imply a race. Mueller's racist mindset could not venture beyond race and invasions! Aryan Theory wrongly dates most Vedic events to be too recent compared to what the Vedic texts themselves tell. This Aryan Theory is a big factor behind the North-South divide and Dravidian Nationalism. Trash this BS Aryan Theory
- —Guest Dilliwala
Aryan Invasion, because...
- The Aryan race as there are no generic. Aryans Hitler are the descendants of Arius who were discndenti of pseudo-Catholic bishop Arius, in fact Jew. The purebred is to be understood as the chosen race of jew-Jews who aspire to the domain religious-political-economic-military in the world. Sorry for my imperfect English
- —Guest Giuseppa
German Stupidity?!
- My response doesn't refer to any subjects of the article on Aryan Invasion but with the comment German stupidity that I consider to be inacceptable, racist and derogatory. First of all: National Socialism has led to inexusable, awful and terific crimes that should never ever occur again in human history. You are calling Germans (in general!) stupid for falling for Hitler. If you would consider the circumstances under which Germans have lived after the First World War you might at least get an understanding why such a horrible, inexusable ideology could get ever proliferated. If you would take real surveys into account and wouldn't believe in myths, you would came to the conclusion that Hitler was not of Jewish ancestry. I am incredibly shocked by your argumentation: how can you even dare to endorse poisening? Isn't that tremendously stupid?! You are criticizing the arrogance of Germans, but isn't your comment highly arrogant and racist too?!
- —Guest ihateidiotyandintolerance
I disagree.
- The theory is nothing else but the arrogance of the European mind.India and India is the original home of THR ARYANS
- —Guest A.V.Vishwarupe
hitler
- i think thaat hitlers aryan race was a bad idea because it was just blond head people and bule eyes and theirs not that many with thoughs kind of traits
- —Guest bob
Wild west
- raaces are quite distinct, as so are individuals-distinct from each other . as for brotherhood of all peole there is no such thing, there are only blood relations and friends. it's impossible for humans to stretch out so far that they encompass all mankind, without watering themselves down. And the africa theory is just that a theory.
- —Guest krish
revealed
- in response to the question of Aryan invasion... or migration outwards and subsequent return... there is finally conclusive evidence to show that Aryan people come from teh people of the Rya... who left India and returned 5000 years ago, after millions of years of human dispersal. Please feel free to read about this controversial and groundbreaking revelation in the book Ithihaasa. It is a complete overhaul of History as we knew it
- —Guest Vijay
literact in pstharappan india
- http://www.scribd.com/doc/127306265/Sujay-Post-Harappan-Literacy-Final-Final-Final
- —Guest sujay rao mandavilli
Aryan is not a race
- One of the most controversial issue related to Aryan Invasion theory,the real meaning of arya is Noble.it is not a race. Aryan invasion theory implemented by European Imperialism and to colonize the Indian sub continent with their self motivation
- —Guest krishna kumar
vasudaivakutumbakam
- irrespective of the region, gender, color and language they speak. We are all one this is what the Hinduism stands for, Vasudaivakutumbakam, which means entire wold is a family. The basic problem with the human nature is dominance, and thus this theory of Aryan Culture has evolved, Arya stands for noble, Max has concoted the history of the region, but one thing he could do good for the region is that he has binded together the entire Aryavrata region, people may feel disgusted to accept this naked truth, Max and the British or the Europeans may have looted the wealth but they could able to conglomerate the entire people of the region. So what I would like to say is when you want to judge some issue never take a stand, if you do so then all the credits which you have will be converted into your debits.
- —Guest Who Are V
Aryan 'invasion'
- Thankful that there is now real science debunking this hoax. We are all one race: human. Aryan refers to behavior, not race.
- —Guest vinaya alahan
Indus superiority
- White people in the ancient times have always been a huge failure, is it not natural of them to make up theories such as the aryan invasion to make themselves seem as good as the great Indus people. The Harrapan civilization needed no white boy to prevail, at that time all whites lived in slums and bathed in crap.
- —Guest Indus beast
1-15 of 115Next
